§1,5: “Death to Machines? A Preliminary Strategic Analysis”
As it is currently conceived and imposed, artificial intelligence is the ultimate ontological generation machine. Politically, it appears as a capitalist ploy to neutralize human intelligences which, in their proletarian social form, have always intelligently challenged it. Artists fall for this ploy when they sing the praises of the artificial imaginaries offered to them, without seeing that the so-called "virtuality" of these technologies is founded on the eviction of all recalcitrant imaginaries—those not already present in the data stream or that have been banished from it by the hegemonic order of language. Readers who have followed this introduction this far might therefore think that the best way to prevent the (environ)mental disaster of AI would be this: smash the machines! No need to look any further, one might say to oneself; the picture painted is grim enough that we know what to do: "Death to machines," as Maria suggests in Metropolis (1927), the film by Fritz Lang that I will return to later.
One could indeed argue that the hundreds of thousands of satellites that will soon clutter the sky deserve to be the targets of our slingshots, as long as they serve only to improve the drone-delivery of pizzas or bombs, to allow online gamers to gain a few seconds for their digital convenience, and to inform machines of the best ways to steer our lives through little "nudges," and existential suggestions, think for example of the app that lets you chat with a later, older version of yourself, who teaches you how to live more fully in the present by offering advice from a simulated future.10
One precaution, however, is in order. Before we rush to grab our slingshots, this book recommends considering the creation and use of "concept-launchers" to challenge automatic thinking, pairing them with "metaphor-launchers" that pierce the digital bubble, passing behind the mirror of ontological generation in order to confront the abyss. Only a prolonged stay in the negative allows one to perceive the images of the excommunicated world. And it is from these nearly erased images, these pending utopias, that it seems necessary to me to think about the ends of politics, and to gauge from there what desirable courses of action, in the face of the (environ)mental disaster, there are. The fact that there are too many machines must not, in fact, lead us to prescribe only a neo-Luddite act; simply deactivating AIs would not be enough. This is true for at least two reasons:
- The first is that the impact of AI on our ability to think and feel—this cognitive and sensory trauma—is already visible, audible, and far more severe than we realize. A social, psychological, and technological reorientation is therefore required—extending even to the ways we communicate and conceive of the common good—if we are to address the already profound impact of AI—the impact of the artificial in the very fabric of our ideas.
- The second, which underlies the first, is that there is no humanity without technology, that is, without the externalization of humanity into tools and machines that shape us by integrating into us, reshaping our social and psychological inner worlds. Such is the anthropological-technological circle: human societies produce technologies, which in turn produce them. What I will seek to illuminate in this book is the way in which this circle is traversed at its center by something utterly inhuman—something unsettling, cosmological, and profoundly enigmatic—around which both the human and technology coil.
My point, then, is not to reject technology in favor of a more natural humanity, but to reject the technology that prevents the expression of that enigmatic element without which there is no humanity—this enigmatic dimension being neither reducible to technology nor to nature. What is missing from contemporary technology is this aspect which, when foreclosed, can only lead to destructive stupidity and a downward trend in the level of human and machine intelligence, a self-negating madness of human reason, an absurdity as failed as the aesthetic failure of AI-produced images.
Endnotes
10 "AI researchers build ‘future self’ chatbot to inspire wise life choices" in The Guardian, June 5, 2024.